Frisky RSS Frisky on Google
news swag bag news what's viral
news

MTV’s Model Makers: Because Eating Disorders Make For Great TV!

Comments (5)
Bookmark and Share

Thin girl

Really MTV? Now, I know I can hardly knock ya too much—after all, The Hills is my vice—but when I read about an upcoming show called Model Makers, I knew maybe my favorite craptastic network had gone too far. Billed as a “Transformation Make-Over” reality show, Model Makers advertised for contestants with the following ad:

Have you always wanted to model but don’t know where to start? Maybe you don’t know the right people. Maybe you are not thin enough. Maybe you are not photogenic.  MODEL MAKERS will give you the ultimate make-over and transform you into the model of your dreams. Women come in all shapes and sizes, but models don’t. The term model conjures an image of stick-thin, towering beauties oozing confidence, glamour, poise and sexuality from every pore. ‘Skinny,’ ‘no body fat,’ and ‘size zero’ are the words and phrases associated with models. ‘Chubby,’ ‘well-fed,’ and ‘big-boned’ are not…

It almost seems like a joke how transparent this show is—while other modeling shows clearly are filled with thin girls (with the exception of last season’s America’s Next Top Model winner Whitney, who broke the scales at a HUGE size 8), they’ve never been so blatant about their industry’s dangerous and shallow standards. MTV’s core demographic is 12 to 24-year-olds, also the age range when most women with eating disorders develop anorexia or bulimia. Couple this show with the recent news that the nation’s most popular teen magazine—Seventeen—is going to develop a line of work out videos for teenagers, and you’ve got a noticeable trend where major media companies are now actively instilling body obsession in girls when they’re at their most vulnerable. Catherine may be boycotting The Hills because she’s disturbed that Lauren Conrad makes a disgusting $75,000 per episode, but I may have to boycott the network as a whole because I am so disgusted.

Tags: eating disorders, mtv, modeling, anorexia, bulimia, seventeen magazine, workout videos

Comments (5)
Bookmark and Share
comments
Leigh Raines's avatar

Leigh Raines
wrote on August 26 2008 @ 11:31 am: [report]

so unbelievable disgusting and scary for our culture might i add


atlgirl's avatar

atlgirl
wrote on August 26 2008 @ 12:03 pm: [report]

Totally see what you’re saying, but are workout videos for teens necessarily bad? I think it’s all about the execution….


Amelia's avatar

Amelia
wrote on August 26 2008 @ 12:20 pm: [report]

@atlgirl I just don’t think that girls who are 14 should be encouraged to buy workout dvds right after reading a magazine filled with skinny perfect models. There are enough pressures to be skinny as it is.


Annika Harris's avatar

Annika Harris
wrote on August 26 2008 @ 01:26 pm: [report]

There’s a trend toward childhood obesity going on now, and while I’m equally disgusted by MTV’s show, I’m not so concerned with Seventeen b/c I think the mag has proven over the years it’s commitment to educating young women about body image. With that said, I think it would also be helpful for Seventeen to include information on how to make healthy food choices. I hope the DVDs will have healthy women of all sizes showing that anyone can workout and be active.


HereComestheSunQ's avatar

HereComestheSunQ
wrote on August 26 2008 @ 02:37 pm: [report]

I actually considered auditioning for this show.  I have great bone structure and a cool look, but there’s no way I could ever be a model at the size I am (12/14) so being able to have the resources to lose the weight and a launching pad would be great.  People are focusing way too much on the fact that it’s about weight so it automatically has to be bad or shallow, not healthy.  I don’t know where they got the description above, but that’s not the audition post on mtv.com and the show asked for women between the ages of 18 and 25, women who are old enough to diet healthily.


Post a Comment

You must be logged in to comment on The Frisky.

Username:
Password:
 

Auto-login on future visits
Show my name in the online users list

 

  register | forgotten password


frisky poll

frisky friends