Frisky RSS Frisky on Google
guys swag bag guys what's viral
guys

Mind Of Man: In Defense Of Gender Stereotypes

Comments (6)
Bookmark and Share

Mind of Man

Recently, I rambled about The Big Switcheroo – men and women adopting each other’s worst gender behaviors. The diatribe was equal parts self-indulgence and genuine confusion. Are men really becoming needy, emotional leeches and women emotionally void predators?  I suppose no one said the collective lurch towards equality was going to be pretty. And I’d like to add that it seems no one is really having any fun. It’s never fun being someone who you’re not.

But enough Danny Downer.

We’re men. This is our shoulder. You may weep on it. Soak it to the bone, we can take it. Your emotionality doesn’t make you a psycho. Our stoic façade doesn’t make us animals.

There is such a thing as a positive gender stereotype; I’m all for equality, but men and women both possess gender-specific qualities that are, well, special. But unique, and worthy of celebration.

Gender stereotypes can be summed up by my interpretation of a stand-up comedy show I was forced to attend recently. The routine is summed up thusly:

“There are many, various amusing differences between men and women. Men are slobs and they think farting is funny. Women are neat freaks, and they do not think farting is funny. By your laughter, I can surmise you recognize that these observations are too true. I shall continue. What is the deal with women always taking so long in the bathroom? And likewise, what is the deal with men always wanting sex. Your laughter validates my comedic analysis.”

Really? Is this really what it’s all about? I am not a feminist; how can I be? And ladies, always be deeply distrustful of sensitive hipster who says he’s a feminist. I just resent the pressure to be binary, to pick a caricature and that’s that. In order to be true to myself, and ourselves, we’ve got to redefine the terms that define us.

Are we really what the pages of GLAMOPOLITAN and BRODAWG magazines tell us we are?

Women have a capacity for emotional depth that men just don’t have. Sorry, that’s the truth. There is no pleasure more sublime than a woman who loves you extinguishing the agony of a bad day with an understanding smile that transcends verbal communication and gooses the outer-realms of the cosmic.

Meanwhile, I truly believe with all my heart that one of the defining masculine traits is strength. Not fake, decorative strength. I’m not talking muscles, or facial scruff, or pursing your lips and flashing gang signs on your MySpace page. I’m talking keeping your head when the excrement hits the fan. Being a man means shouldering the problems of those you love long enough for them to find their balance.

Being a man means killing the zombies first, and later, telling your woman how scared you were. And one day, maybe that can flip.

And when the world becomes too much for you, we can be leaned on. You can expose yourself in all your clumsy, human glory and we won’t be scared. We’re men. This is our shoulder. You may weep on it. Soak it to the bone, we can take it. Your emotionality doesn’t make you a psycho. Our stoic façade doesn’t make us animals.

The ancient symbols for men and women are, respectively, ♂ and ♀.  The male symbol stands for Aries’ spear and shield, the female, Aphrodite’s mirror. In these symbols are the best and worst of our gender. Violent aggression for men, and vanity for women (narcissism sounds like a diagnosis; vanity is a vice.)

But these symbols also represent the best virtues of the sexes. Aries’ shield can also symbolize courage, which is the act of deciding something in this life is more important than fear. And Aphrodite’s mirror can also symbolize introspection and wisdom, which is knowing and loving who you are. The first step to loving those in your life.  Personally, I aspire to both positive gender stereotypes.

If you’ve read this far, you have my permission to vomit.

Let’s celebrate our respective gender awesomeness a little more. And then we can return to making a world where we are equal, except for the things that make us unique.

Tags: mind of man, what men think, john devore, gender stereotypes

Comments (6)
Bookmark and Share
comments
Andrea Learned's avatar

Andrea Learned
wrote on July 28 2008 @ 07:56 am: [report]

Everyone aspiring to their positive gender attributes (maybe if we don’t call them stereotypes it will sound less negative?) would be a dream world, John.  Thanks for your perspective.


AC's avatar

AC
wrote on July 28 2008 @ 09:25 am: [report]

Speaking of gender stereotypes, I guess we can figure heterosexuality into the equation.  If we do, then I will claim that nothing changes some fundamental facts of the sexual act.  Guys are generally bigger/stronger, potentially dangerous, the active invaders.  As long as heterosexual sex exists, there will be fundamental perception of men being potentially dangerous (or yummy) aggressors and women as relatively vulnerable receptors.

I know some will have a strong knee-jerk reaction against that claim, but it is undeniable that women fear men more than men fear women.  Further, women fear men more than men fear other men.  Now why is that?


girlgerms's avatar

girlgerms
wrote on July 28 2008 @ 12:18 pm: [report]

No offense, but this article reads like it’s out of the 1980’s.  Go to any urban center with a large LGBT population and then please recant this sexist nonsense.


JohnDeVore's avatar

JohnDeVore
wrote on July 28 2008 @ 12:45 pm: [report]

No offense taken. Care to elaborate more?


girlgerms's avatar

girlgerms
wrote on July 28 2008 @ 12:57 pm: [report]

There are many women who would fight zombies and not feel scared at all.  There are men who would have their brains eaten and not fight back.  There are women in full contact bloody roller derby teams and men in drag troupes in almost every medium-sized or larger city.

Yes, your gender stereotypes are true more often than the reverse, but that doesn’t mean they are inevitable or that people who don’t follow them are doing something wrong.  It’s like saying “women are good at writing and men are good at math—let’s celebrate our differences!”  It’s mostly true, but at the same time, really wrong. 

We should be encouraging women who like math and men who are emotional (for example), because life can be a lot harder for them than for the women and men in the majority.


bluewater's avatar

bluewater
wrote on August 27 2008 @ 08:10 am: [report]

You are clearly correct that in a larger metropolitian area, these characteristics can be flip flopped or challenged regularly. I think John is simply stating that we should all play to our strengths. Our historical characteristics as man and woman should not be something we fight to overcome, but embrace them and show that they do not need to have negative connotations. So maybe that means they are feminine and masculine characteristics that in todays society can be applied to either sex.
I happen to be a female that considers myself wise, introspective, extremely sensitive at times, and often find the unwavering strength of a guy very comforting. That doesnt mean that if you piss me off or threaten me I would hesitate to try to kick your ass. And, not gonna lie, there have been times when I have been upset and cried or gotten upset for no reason and I can get away with it because I am a girl.
I dont think sexual orientation and sexism have anything to do with this. Play to your strengths, whether they are god given or not.


Post a Comment

You must be logged in to comment on The Frisky.

Username:
Password:
 

Auto-login on future visits
Show my name in the online users list

 

  register | forgotten password


frisky poll

frisky friends