Bachelor: Bob Guiney
Who He Chose: Estella Gardinier
Who He Should Have Chose: Meredith Phillips
Bachelor Bob, as he was known, was immensely popular with viewers when he was a contestant on Trista Rehn's season of "The Bachelorette," so much so that he became "The Bachelor," despite being a little tubbier than the stars of these shows are usually allowed. Anyway, in the end, Bob chose between Estella and Kelly Jo and Estella won -- only to be dumped, like, a hot second after the finale aired. Bob went on to marry and then divorce soap star Rebecca Budig, but I think he would have been better off if he had kept Meredith Phillips around to the end and gave her the final rose. Meredith was amazing -- smart, funny, cultured, beautiful but in a totally unique way -- and she and Bob clicked. Frankly, she was way too good for Bachelor BLOB, but this is about who he should have chosen, not whether she should have accepted.
Who He Chose: Estella Gardinier
Who He Should Have Chose: Meredith Phillips
Bachelor Bob, as he was known, was immensely popular with viewers when he was a contestant on Trista Rehn's season of "The Bachelorette," so much so that he became "The Bachelor," despite being a little tubbier than the stars of these shows are usually allowed. Anyway, in the end, Bob chose between Estella and Kelly Jo and Estella won -- only to be dumped, like, a hot second after the finale aired. Bob went on to marry and then divorce soap star Rebecca Budig, but I think he would have been better off if he had kept Meredith Phillips around to the end and gave her the final rose. Meredith was amazing -- smart, funny, cultured, beautiful but in a totally unique way -- and she and Bob clicked. Frankly, she was way too good for Bachelor BLOB, but this is about who he should have chosen, not whether she should have accepted.
