Michelle Williams & Jeremy Jackson

What Actually Happened: The former "Baywatch" star (he played David Hasselhoff's son, incase you lived under a rock) turned steroid addict says that young Michelle Williams  "was kind of like my first crush, puppy dog love," according to Us Weekly. Williams guest starred on an episode of "Baywatch" and that's where the two met. Jackson kind of grossly revealed that many of his first sexual experiences were with Williams and that the actress was his "secret rendezvous girlfriend."

What Could Have Happened If They Stayed Together: Forget "Dawson's Creek," "Brokeback Mountain," and a epic love story with the late Heath Ledger. An extended run on "Baywatch" -- made possible by her serious relationship with Jackson -- would have killed Michelle's growth as an actress. Luckily, I think Michelle has the emotional strength not to follow Jackson down his road to addiction, but she might have stuck by him and been showing up at family hour at Dr. Drew's Celebrity Rehab Clinic. Sadz.

Level Of Relief This Couple Was Not Meant To Be: High