Debate This: Would You Rather Have An Antique Or A New Engagement Ring?

When it comes to the engagement game, each girl has her own fantasy. But enquiring minds want to know … would you prefer a vintage/antique ring from an auction house, estate sale, vintage store, or family member? Or do you want something brand spankin’ new like a Tiffany 2-karat Lucida three-stone setting with a platinum band? (Just sayin’.)

We invite the un-marrieds and the already blinged-out marrieds to leave their opinions in the comments below.